Tyra Banks is taking Netflix to court. The model, producer, and longtime host of America’s Next Top Model filed a defamation lawsuit on Saturday June 13th, claiming that the streaming giant’s documentary series Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model used selective editing to construct a false and damaging portrait of her — one that she says implied she allowed a contestant to be sexually assaulted on her show, exploited that contestant’s trauma for ratings, and could not even remember it when asked.
Banks says she agreed to participate in the documentary precisely because she wanted to be accountable — on the record, in her own words, for viewers who had watched ANTM across its 22 cycles. She sat for a three-and-a-half-hour interview and placed no restrictions on what topics the interviewer could raise. Just 16 minutes of that footage made it into the final cut, she claims, stripped of context and reassembled to support a narrative she never endorsed and does not recognise as true.
“The false narrative the producers constructed — through selective editing, deliberate omission, and surgical manipulation of continuous footage — included that Ms. Banks knowingly allowed a contestant to be sexually assaulted on her show, exploited that contestant’s trauma for ratings, and then could not even remember it when asked,” the lawsuit states. “That narrative about Ms. Banks is a complete fabrication — one that Netflix streamed to a global audience of millions.”
Banks is requesting a jury trial and seeking damages for loss of future business opportunities, loss of business income, and significant mental anguish.
The Shandi Sullivan Footage — and What Banks Says Was Cut
The most serious allegation in the lawsuit centres on cycle 2 contestant Shandi Sullivan, who described in the Netflix documentary being blackout drunk when male models came to the house where contestants were staying during filming in Italy, and accused production of framing what she considers a sexual assault as a cheating storyline involving her boyfriend back home.
Banks was asked about Shandi during her interview. According to the lawsuit, the documentary edited her response to imply she could not remember the contestant’s story at all. Banks says the full, unedited footage tells a completely different story — that she nodded affirmatively and immediately said “I do remember her story” before the clip was cut. She alleges producers removed the nod and that sentence entirely, leaving only the pause that followed, and presenting it to viewers as confusion or ignorance.
ALSO READ: Jeremy Strong Is Mark Zuckerberg in Aaron Sorkin’s Social Network Sequel — Watch the First Trailer
“By carving the nod out of the middle of the sequence and cutting off Ms. Banks’ comment at the end, the producers ensured that viewers would see only the lie and not the truth,” the lawsuit states. Banks also says she was unaware, going into her interview, that Sullivan had classified what happened to her as sexual assault — and that this context was never provided to her before she was asked about it.
The lawsuit also addresses a separate allegation that appears in the docuseries — that Banks failed to take action when crew misconduct occurred during production. Banks disputes this directly. She says that during one cycle of ANTM, a crew member reported to her that a regular cast member had engaged in a pattern of inappropriate sexual conduct. She says she immediately escalated the matter to other executives and to the network, that production was paused, and that the entire cast and crew underwent sexual harassment training delivered by an outside expert. None of this, she says, was included in the documentary.
Miss J, Text Messages and Two Years of Unanswered Contact
A secondary but personally painful thread in the lawsuit involves ANTM judge Miss J Alexander, who said in the docuseries that Banks had never visited him after his 2022 stroke and had only sent a text. Banks does not dispute the text. She disputes everything that was left unsaid around it.
The lawsuit states that Banks had been living in Australia for two and a half years at the time of the stroke, that she made repeated attempts to reach Miss J directly — calls and messages that initially went unanswered because his family was focused on his recovery — and that when contact was eventually made, the two spent three years communicating through voice notes, photos, video messages, and texts. As recently as Christmas Day 2025, she and Miss J exchanged holiday messages and she asked to speak that week. They never did. Weeks later, the Netflix documentary aired.
Banks says producers never informed her that Miss J’s comments about the hospital visit would be part of the series, which meant she had no opportunity to provide the text records, call logs, or family communications that would have provided full context. “Again, the producers deprived viewers of truth by withholding from Ms. Banks the information about what others had said in their Netflix interviews and not providing her with an opportunity to respond,” the lawsuit says.
Banks is not without defenders. Cycle 8 winner Jaslene González told reporters she has nothing but gratitude for Banks and said her view of ANTM’s legacy has not changed. PR professional Kelly Cutrone, who appeared on cycles 18 through 22, said she believed “80 percent” of the docuseries was “incredibly twisted” and predicted that “the facts and the truth will come forward.” Cutrone did not participate in the Netflix series.
Netflix has not yet responded publicly to the lawsuit.
Stay informed. Subscribe to the JournalTodays Newsletter for the latest celebrity legal news, entertainment updates, and media coverage delivered straight to your inbox.
